Daily Archives: August 2, 2012

Fake Drugs will not Cure Malaria

The latest assault on malaria is unprecedented. Last year an array of organisations, including the Roll Back Malaria Partnership, based at the WHO and founded in 1998, the Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria, founded in 2002, and the President’s Malaria Initiative, founded under George Bush in 2005, spent a record $2 billion fighting it.  The Roll Back Malaria Partnership has set goals for 2015 that include the heroic aim of cutting malaria deaths to near zero. This would mean more than doubling spending, to $5 billion a year. Mr Chambers is trying to rally the troops. The report he is to present estimates the benefits of fighting malaria in sub-Saharan Africa, which is reckoned to have accounted for nine-tenths of worldwide deaths from the disease in 2010.

Universal deployment of good treatment, diagnostics and preventive measures, including bed nets, would—in theory—prevent 640m malaria cases and 3m deaths by 2015, the paper explains. This would cost at least $6.7 billion between 2012 and 2015, says the African Leaders Malaria Alliance, a regional lobby. But, says the report, it would be a brilliant investment, yielding an astonishing $231 billion-$311 billion, counted in lives saved and malaria cases averted, if you factor in productivity gains and savings in the cost of treatment.

That $6.7 billion is not likely to materialise in its entirety soon. Nor does it include the cost of training health workers and improving surveillance. Problems of counterfeit or substandard medicines are particularly worrying. Tanzanian regulators recently seized 155 containers of fake anti-malarials. Since 2010 the Global Fund has subsidised the private market for the best anti-malaria drugs, known as artemisinin-combination therapies (ACTs). But Roger Bate of the American Enterprise Institute, a think-tank, found that 8% of subsidised ACTs in his sample had too little of the active ingredient. Moreover, those mosquitoes are beginning to resist ACTs and popular insecticides. The battle is far from over.

Fighting Malaria: Net benefit, Economist July 14, 2012, at 42

See also Malaria’s Deaths